Quick Review (LP): Mermaid Avenue II by Wilco (+ Billy Bragg)

Wilco (+ Billy Bragg)
Mermaid Avenue II
Elektra; 2000

My Rating: C (54/100)

Best Tracks: "Airline to Heaven", "Secret of the Sea", "Remember the Mountain Bed", "Aginst th’ Law", "I Was Born"

TRACK NOTES

"Airline to Heaven" (4.5/5)

  • Love the hoedown rhythm.
  • The direction this tune takes is pretty genius. Sounds like it could’ve been an Uncle Tupelo cut.

"My Flying Saucer" (4/5)

  • Cute n’ catchy.

"Feed of Man" (3.5/5)

  • Sort of menacing, but ultimately forgettable.
  • Tweedy should stick to the pretty stuff.

"Hot Rod Hotel" (3.5/5)

  • Woody’s lyrics are pretty great, but musically this is below average.

"I Was Born" (4/5)

  • Another cutey.
  • I was never a 10,000 Maniacs fan, but Natalie Merchant’s super-pure voice really works well with Woody’s lyrics and BB’s tunes.

"Secret of the Sea" (5/5)

  • LOVE this one.
  • Power pop brilliance. (Must be Jay B’s tune
  • "Who can guess the secret of the sea/If you can guess the secret of my love for you/Then we both could know/The secret of the sea…"

"Stetson Kennedy" (3/5)

  • Meh…
  • Sort of sounds like something I’d hear in the background on Bourbon Street.

"Remember the Mountain Bed" (5/5)

  • While Bragg gets the upper hand in terms of authenticity, Tweedy wins in terms of gorgeous melodies. Witness this.
  • Reminds me of the lovelorn nostalgia of "One by One.
  • Great lyrics here.

"Blood of the Lamb" (3/5)

  • Shoots for significance, hits on dull.

"Aginst th’ Law" (4.5/5)

  • Yessir, it is.
  • Why Winston-Salem?
  • Catchy as heck. Fun. Great performance by Corey Harris.

"All You Fascists" (3/5)

  • Yeah, Woody didn’t like Fascists either.
  • Exceedingly average.

"Joe Dimaggio’s Done It Again" (3.5/5)

  • I know it’s Woody’s work and all, but this sounds a bit out of place coming from Tweedy.

"Meanest Man" (3.5/5)

  • Instrumentally compelling.
  • Vocally, decent.
  • In terms of the songwriting, blah.

"Black Wind Blowing" (4/5)

  • Haunting.
  • Picture listening to this one while a storm is rolling in on the prairie.

"Someday Some Morning Sometime" (3.5/5)

  • Feels like it could have been a bit more…

ALBUM NOTES

  • Well, they saved most of the winners for the first volume. "Secret of the Sea" is essentially perfect, a Wilco power-pop wonder. Otherwise, there’s not a whole lot that detonates.
  • I wonder if they’ve ever given thought to continuing this series?
  • There’s a good documentary about the recording sessions called Man In The Sand. You can watch it on Netflix instant (or, you know, buy it or something).
  • Now that Wilco’s done this for two albums, it would be interesting to hear Jay Farrar/Son Volt give it a shot. After all, JF has always seemed to exude the blue collar heart.

ATTRIBUTES
Cohesion (4/5)
Concept (4/5)
Consequence (3.5/5)
Consistency (2.5/5)
Songs (3.83/5)

5 Things: “Secret of the Sea” by Billy Bragg/Wilco

5 things I love about “Secret of the Sea”…

1. It’s Woody Guthrie and power pop all in one.
2. “If you could guess the secret of my love for you/Then we both could know the secret of the sea”
3. The ragtime piano breakdown.
4. Tweedy’s vox, some of his best ever.
5. Bennett’s slide work, one of his signature sounds.

What do you love about this track?